Monday, August 11, 2008
This Year, Fraud Will Cost Businesses $994 Billion in the U.S.!
In their just released Report to the Nation on Occupational Fraud and Abuse, the average case cost a business $175,000. In a quarter of 959 cases used to compile the study, the loss was $1 million or more. The most costly type of fraud was financial statement fraud -- more commonly known as cooking the books -- which cost organizations an average of $2 million.
Not surprisingly, smaller businesses suffered the greatest losses. I say not surprisingly, because smaller businesses normally can't afford dedicated resources to detect and prevent fraud. For small businesses, the average case studied cost about $200,000.
The most common type of fraud found in the study was corruption and the second most common was fraudulent billing. The average scheme wasn't detected for two years and the most common form of detection was from a human being tipping off management, or a business owner.
In the small business fraud model, check tampering was a common cause, also.
Businesses that had fraud controls did a lot better than businesses that didn't, according to the study. For instance, businesses that did surprise audits suffered an average loss of $70,000, while businesses that didn't suffered an average loss of $207,000. Other controls that made an impact cited in the report are anonymous hot lines, training management to detect fraud and hiring dedicated personnel to detect and resolve fraud.
According to the report, fraud perpetrators can be identified by the behaviors they display. These include living beyond their means, financial difficulties or even by trying to please their boss by making it appear that the business is doing better than it really is. Please note that in the case of larger corporations, the word "boss" can mean investors or shareholders.
Please note there are many more signs of dishonesty and recommended controls for small business owners. Another good resource to read about these subjects is put out by the National Association of Veterans' Research and Education Foundation.
The extensive report covers all type of fraud, whether they are financial, or otherwise. The three main categories it is broken down into are Corruption, Asset Misappropriation and Fraudulent statements. Corruption schemes entail bribery, conflicts of interest, illegal gratuities and economic extortion. Asset Misappropriation schemes (most common) cover cash manipulation, inventory theft, and fraudulent disbursements.
For those businesses, who can't afford hired help to deal with fraud, I guess this means a owner should check their books and accounts randomly without letting their employees know when they are going to do it. They should also diversify controls and oversight (separate key duties). No one person should have complete control over a revenue stream or valuable asset. Additionally -- there are third-party anonymous hot line services and if they are too expensive -- a creative small business owner might set up a telephone line with a voice mail and have some posters made.
So far as training management and employees on what to be aware of -- the current AFCE report is a wealth of information, also. A little awareness and knowledge of how fraud is facilitated can go a long way towards preventing it, as well as, giving your human resources the knowledge to spot and report it.
Most fraud is defeated by people, who are knowledgeable of what to look for. This is because fraud schemes rely on tricking everyone else to think nothing is going on.
On a final note, if you are a small business owner and detect fraud, I recommend leaving any legal recourse matters to someone who is familiar with how to do it. Handling these matters the wrong way can add to the problem by causing other losses, such as civil litigation or the protecting yourself against it. In any situation, where a crime is detected, the best thing to do is to contact the authorities and seek their assistance with it.
Tuesday, June 05, 2007
Merchants demand their rights from the payment (credit/debit) card industry!
Additionally, merchants aren't only becoming more alarmed by fraud, but also by a perception that current fee structures are unfair, and deceptive. Interestingly enough, a lot of consumers feel the same way, also.
- Only 26 percent of participants believe they are being treated fairly by the debit/ credit/prepaid card processing industry.
- Only 32 percent understand unfair card processing practices and how they impact their business.
- Only 21 percent understand the rates, fees and surcharges they pay.
- Only 15 percent believe they are charged the same as larger businesses.
The survey was sponsored by Heartland Payment Systems, who processes payment card transactions and payroll.
Heartland's CEO and Chairman, Bob Carr stated:
It’s clear that many owners of small and mid-sized businesses don’t understand the complexities of card acceptance. Yet, card acceptance is often one of the three largest expenses they incur. Business owners need to educate themselves so they can manage these costs. What they don’t know may be hurting their bottom line.
According to the press release, the bill of rights promotes fairness and transparency in card processing by identifying 10 fundamental rights:
The right to know the fee for every card transaction – and who’s charging it.
The right to know the markup of Visa and MasterCard fee increases.
The right to know all Visa and MasterCard fee reductions.
The right to know all transaction middlemen.
The right to know all surcharges and bill-backs.
The right to a dedicated local service representative.
The right to encrypted card numbers and secure transactions.
The right to real-time fraud and transaction monitoring.
The right to reasonable equipment costs.
The effort has a home page, which can be viewed, here.
The page has a video for merchants to see if their rights are being violated, here.
The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners recognizes that small businesses suffer greater losses than larger ones do. I did a post on this subject, with the some tips on how to avoid becoming a victim, here.
In January, I did a post about how both consumers and merchants are calling for some reforms:
Congress needs to take a hard look at credit practices
In this post, I mentioned the Merchant's Payment Coalition, which is calling for greater oversight on some of this. Their page on unfair credit card fees can be viewed, here.
Even if you aren't a merchant, the truth is that these costs have to be passed off somewhere; otherwise merchants would go out of business. Who do you think ultimately pays for all this?
Sunday, August 20, 2006
ACFE Issues Study on Fraud in the Workplace
The report takes into account actual cases conducted by members of their organization over the past two years. In about 25 percent of the cases studies - the loss was $1,000,000.00, or greater.
Another finding from the report is that small businesses seem to suffer "disproportionate fraud losses," when compared to larger organizations.
An interesting aspect to this report is that government and non-profit organizations were studied, also. There certainly has been a lot in the news about fraud in these sectors.
The report came to the conclusion that most businesses lose 5% of their revenue to fraud and cites that if this were translated to the U.S. gross domestic product it could mean we lose $652 billion to fraud every year.
Also cited in the report were controls by industry and their effectiveness. The controls measures were external audit, internal audit, fraud training, surprise audits and the use of fraud hotlines.
The report admits it's hard to put a dollar amount on fraud, because if it's not detected, it's normally not "advertised." Nonetheless, the report seems to be extremely factual and I've never seen anyone, who was able to put an exact dollar amount on fraud losses, or their causes.
Even when investigated thoroughly - there are "unknowns" and the best anyone can do is try to make an honest deduction.
If you would like to view the full report, it can be found on their website, here.
