Showing posts sorted by relevance for query ebay scams. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query ebay scams. Sort by date Show all posts

Thursday, May 04, 2006

BIN (Buy it Now) Scams on eBay

Fraud on eBay has victimized a lot of people AND eBay rarely admits fault, or takes effective action against the fraudsters. The latest activity seems to be BIN (Buy it Now) scams.

Ina Steiner of AuctionBytes reports:

"Over the past month, eBay sellers on U.S. discussion boards have been discussing the problem of Chinese "BIN bandits" on eBay. The problem described by posters is that newly registered, zero-feedback members from China are buying BIN (Buy It Now) items from eBay sellers in a systematic fashion, and not following through on the transactions."

It seems the intent of these BIN (Buy it Now) scams is to get the merchandise shipped (0ff-eBay) and pay for it via a payment scam. This might be done with fraudulent cashiers checks (rampant in the world of internet fraud), or with one of the fraudulent debit/credit card numbers (sold in Internet Relay Chat) chatrooms OR even with one of the counterfeit money orders that are flooding the world of Internet scams.

Another problem with this scam is eBay refunding the fees to sellers when one of these BIN bandits backs out of a transaction. There seems to be a lot of "negative feedback" regarding eBay's process to get the fees refunded. Allegations are that the process is full of red tape and it often is difficult to get a refund.

Ms. Steiner stated in her article:

"One seller alleges that in a previous BIN bandit episode that lasted over 7 months, eBay only took action when sellers flooded the California and New York Attorneys General's offices with complaints."

Another speculation from the article is:

"Some eBay sellers have speculated that the BIN bandits might be members of eBay's affiliate program who receive generous compensation for sending new bidders to eBay.com. In the U.S., affiliates can earn between 40 - 70 percent of eBay's revenue on winning bids or Buy It Now transactions within 7 days of an affiliate action. Affiliates also earn between $12 and $20 for each new active confirmed registered user (ACRU) driven to eBay (http://affiliates.ebay.com/)."

Link to article from AuctionBytes, here.

eBay is taking limited action, but only the sort that won't limit their profits. For one, they suggest only using PayPal (which they own and profit from) and there are a lot of people out there, who prefer other methods of payment.

The article refers to a lot of this coming from China, but other points of compromise could be Nigeria, Singapore and those Eastern European nations. "Buy it Now" fraud seems to be the latest mutation of Auction fraud, which sometimes includes Advance Fee scams.

When reading the AuctionBytes article, I came across a great site dedicated to fraud on eBay (eBayMotorsSucks). The site is very up-to-date and a great resource to protect people. I highly recommend it.

Here are some previous posts, I've done on Auction fraud:

Do It Yourself Hacker Kits

25 Ways to Avoid Auction Fraud From a Seller's Perspective

eBay's Fraud Hall of Shame

Saturday, February 18, 2006

eBay's Fraud Hall of Shame

eBay's revenue continues to grow AND despite a growing number of victims, they seem to be blame everyone, but themselves. I recently wrote a post: How Much Fraud Can eBay's Customers Endure? There are some pretty good descriptions (with references) on this post about all of the various forms of fraud found on eBay.

Fraudulent forms of payment, Advance fee fraud (419) scams, phishing and account takeovers are common. Counterfeit merchandise and misleading ads abound on the site and by the time there is any response by eBay, the damage is often done.

So far as misleading ads, here is a post, I did during the Christmas Season: XBox Latest Lure in Auction Scams. People were tricked into buying the box, versus the contents by ads, which were written in a deceptive manner.

Yahoo's Group, eBayFraud is trying to do something about it. In their own words, here is what they are working towards accomplishing:

"This Group is designed to share information regarding fraud on eBay, including law enforcement, legal proceedings, reimbursement and fraud prevention. Members are welcome to post links, files, databases and messages that are relevant to this topic. You can also use the chat function for more direct communication."

I was recently contacted by them and asked to help publicize their efforts.

Here from the site is a compilation of articles about the fraud problem on eBay. Essentially, this is eBay's Fraud Hall of Shame:

Department of Homeland Security and NCSA 2006 Emerging Internet Threat List
2/17/06


This tidbit, is from www.staysafeonline.org:

http://www.staysafeonline.info/basics/2006threatlist.html

Authorities unable to track most money lost to alleged eBay scam

On 2/9/06, Chris W. Colby of www.naplesnews.com wrote this:

Authorities are unable to track lost money to alleged eBay scam

Seeing Fakes, Angry Traders Confront Ebay

1/29/06 Katie Hafner of www.nytimes.com, wrote:

http://www.nytimes.com/2006/01/29/technology/29ebay.html

Warrants for Arrest Issued in eBay Scam Case

On 1/26/06, a press release from www.colliersheriff.org, stated:

http://www.colliersheriff.org/news/today/todaydetails.asp?nkey=914

2005 Fraud Trends: Consumers Being Hounded by Internet and Telemarketing Scams

1/19/06, NCL News, wrote:

http://nclnet.org/news/2006/2005_fraud_trends_01192006.htm

2005 Fraud Trends: Official Report

http://www.fraud.org/2005_fraud_trend_report.pdf

Consumers Question eBay's Security

On 12/20/05, Martin H. Bosworth of www.consumeraffairs.com, wrote:

http://www.consumeraffairs.com/news04/2005/ebay_fraud.html

eBay Admits Growing Fraud Problems

On 12/16/05, Geoff Duncan of Designtechnica News, wrote:

http://news.designtechnica.com/article9083.html

SAN ANTONIO MAN CONVICTED OF EBAY SCAM

On 3/3/05, John Yembrick of the United States Attorney General for the Southern District of Texas wrote:

http://www.usdoj.gov/usao/txs/releases/March2005/050303-Schoffner.htm

Online auction scams soar, Complaints nearly double

On 2/2/05, Carolyn Said, Chronicle Staff Writer (www.SFGate.com) wrote:

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2005/02/02/COMPLAINTS.TMP

AND these are but stories from the past year, or so.

Here is another telling statistic, which reveals eBay's refusal to face up to reality. When reporting the top ten scams of the year, the National Consumers League noted:

"In the fall of 2003, online giant eBay removed the link from it's site, http://www.fraud.org. As a result, the number of auction complaints reported dropped to 1/6 its previous level. Based on statistics prior to eBay's action, NCL estimates that there would have been 30,720 auction complaints in 2005, representing 71 percent of complaints."

Should eBay continue to IGNORE this problem AND fail to get in front of it, the number of victims will continue to grow.

Sunday, January 29, 2006

How Much Fraud Can eBay's Customers Endure

Fraud on eBay is making news again, this time for upset customers being sold counterfeit goods. Here is an article by Katie Hafner of the New York Times:

"A year ago Jacqui Rogers, a retiree in southern Oregon who dabbles in vintage costume jewelry, went on eBay and bought 10 butterfly brooches made by Weiss, a well-known maker of high-quality costume jewelry in the 1950s and 1960s.

Rogers thought she had snagged a great deal. But when the jewelry arrived from a seller in Rhode Island, her well-trained eye told her all the pieces were knockoffs. Even though Rogers received a refund after she confronted the seller, eBay refused to remove hundreds of listings for identical "Weiss" pieces. It said it had no responsibility for the fakes because it was nothing more than a marketplace that links buyers and sellers.

That stance — the heart of eBay's business model — is being challenged by eBay users such as Rogers who are starting to notify other unsuspecting buyers of fakes on the site. And it is being tested by a jewelry seller with far greater resources than Rogers: Tiffany & Co., which has sued eBay for facilitating the trade of counterfeit Tiffany items on the site.

If Tiffany wins, other lawsuits would follow and eBay's business model would be threatened because it would be nearly impossible for the company to police a site that has 180 million members and 60 million items for sale at any time."

For the full story, read: eBay users fed up with fakes.

eBay hasn't only been in the news recently for being a marketplace for counterfeit goods. In a recent post, I covered the problem of stolen goods being sold and merchandise being purchased with fraudulent financial instruments.

Also covered in this post is the growing problem of buyer/seller accounts being hijacked. This normally occurs when a seller becomes a victim of phishing, or is tricked into giving up their account information to a seemingly legitimate eBay request via e-mail. The e-mail links them to an official looking eBay site, where they are asked to "validate" their account information. Should someone fall for this, the criminal has all the information necessary to hijack the account and use it (the account) to conduct fraudulent business.

Although, eBay's official policy is to support law enforcement requests without a subpoena, it takes them 10-20 days to honor these requests. If criminals have access to multiple accounts and fraudulent financial tools, the trail is likely to be pretty cold in 10-20 days.

Here is my post on that activity: Better Teamwork is an Opportunity.

eBay is also getting a reputation for Advance fee fraud (419) activity. On auction sites, fraudulent buyers offer to buy something and send a financial instrument to the seller for more than the asking price. They then dupe the seller into negotiating the instrument, which is counterfeit and wiring the excess money (less a commission for the seller) overseas. When the instrument is discovered to be fraudulent (often much later), the seller is held accountable and could even be charged with a crime.

Counterfeit Postal Money Orders, Cashiers Checks and a new type of instrument, OChex (checks ordered electronically over the internet) have all been used in these frauds, which are becoming collectively known as auction scams.

Over the Christmas season, we saw another scam, where XBox packaging was being sold as the real thing: XBox Latest Lure in Auction Scams.

I wrote this in a recent post, eBay Needs to Protect Those that Line it's Pockets:

"My message to the folks at eBay is that they better take a look at upgrading their "authentication systems" and hire some extra security staff. Blogs like mine and many others are trying to educate the very people, who are making them billions and they blame for allowing themselves to be scammed. eBay is no longer the only the only game out there and if they fail to protect those who line their pockets, they are likely to go elsewhere."

Perhaps a few legal actions will wake eBay up?

Friday, July 28, 2006

Communications Law Centre Cites 48 Percent of Auction Customers Report Having a Negative Experience

According to the Communications Law Centre (Australia) 48 percent of the people they surveyed reported having a problem with a auction transaction.

Nick Galvin in the Sydney Morning Herald reports:

"Forty-eight per cent of the auction users surveyed by the Communications Law Centre said they had experienced problems when buying an item. Most often they did not receive the goods they had paid for or, where the item was received, it was not the same as had been described on the site."

eBay Australia disputes this figure:

eBay's director of trust and safety, Alastair MacGibbon, said he had "severe questions" about the conclusions in the report.

"If there was even a remote chance the [centre's] figures were even marginally correct there is no way we would have survived a weekend let alone 10 years on the internet," he said.

Mr MacGibbon said the survey was inadequate and open to bias because it had been conducted online. However, he declined to reveal eBay's own figures on online fraud, other than to repeat that a "fraction of one per cent" of the transactions on the site resulted in confirmed fraud.

Link to Australia story, here.

Interestingly enough, there are stories throughout the world that support the Australian claim. In February, I did on a post - where the NCL (National Consumers League) released the top ten scams of 2005. In the report, which lists auction fraud as the "number-one" problem - they added a "telling" paragraph:

In the fall of 2003, online giant eBay removed the link from its Web site to fraud.org. As a result, the number of auction complaints reported to NCL's fraud center dropped to 1/6 its previous level. Based on statistics prior to eBay's action, NCL estimates that there would have been 30,720 auction complaints in 2005, representing 71 percent of complaints.

Link, here.

More recently, the State of California (where eBay is located) issued an alert on an "emerging" eBay fraud trend:

California Issues Alert on Emerging eBay Fraud Trend

And for a British perspective from the BBC on eBay fraud, link here.

eBay's take in this story was to blame their own "users." The reason eBay cited was (users) having their accounts taken over - because they responded to "phishing" e-mails and didn't have their computers protected properly.

Just this week, Sophos announced that 75 percent of the phishing attempts they saw target eBay and PayPal users. Normally, the intent is to "take over" an eBay, or PayPal account and use the account to commit fraud.

For the report by Sophos, link here.

eBay is immensely popular and loved by many. They are being targeted by criminals and this isn't their fault. Instead of down playing the amount of fraud - they need to take another approach - which is a "zero tolerance" attitude towards it.

After all -- should they fail to do so -- they will continue to be targeted and might lose the most important asset they have, which is their customer.

Until then, the main line of defense is to continue to educate the user and recommend that (all the users) support the fight against fraud on eBay by reporting what they see.

So far as the phishing attempts - a good place to report them is PIRT (Phishing Incident Reporting and Termination Squad) run by CastleCops and Sunbelt Software.

PIRT is run by a lot of dedicated volunteers - who like many of us - are sick and tired of seeing people get taken.

A great educational resource - to share with others and written by a eBay user - which is the subject of a previous post is:

25 Ways to Avoid Auction Fraud From a Seller's Perspective

And if you want to have a "safer" shopping experience on eBay, there is a service that bonds sellers and once they are bonded; guarantees the transaction. Here is a post, I did on buySAFE:

buySAFE Protects it's Customers from Fraud on eBay

Saturday, December 17, 2005

eBay Needs to Protect Those that Line it's Pockets

The amount of fraud on auction sites has been steadily increasing and auctions are under attack by fraudsters, who use many methods to commit their financial misdeeds, or combinations thereof. Seller accounts are being taken over and users are victims of phishing scams. Counterfeit, recalled and stolen merchandise is routinely for sale AND fraudulent means of payment are being used to purchase items.

Does it seem like a "Scam Free for All?"

The BBC recently reported:

"Criminals are obtaining the secret passwords of eBay subscribers and using their sites to conduct bogus auctions for non-existent goods.

In a growing number of cases, would-be buyers on the UK's most used website are paying thousands of pounds to apparently reputable sellers after winning auctions on the site - only to find out they had been dealing with criminals."

eBay seems to prefer to blame phishing for the accounts being taken over and blames their users for falling for the scams. They are also blaming users for not having the proper security software on their systems, which leads to malicious software (mainly Keyloggers) being used to steal personal and financial information.

Amazingly enough, the report also states that it can take up to five days to shut down a site selling counterfeit goods and two months to provide information to law enforcement. This means (to me) that since these scams "rotate and mutate" every few days (often using stolen user information) that no one, or only the "stupid" are being caught. By the time (anyone who could do something) can obtain the necessary information, the criminals have moved on to a different identity and the process has to be started all over again.

For the entire story by the BBC, read eBay faces up to online fraud.

My message to the folks at eBay is that they better take a look at upgrading their "authentication systems" and hire some extra security staff. Blogs like mine and many others are trying to educate the very people, who are making them billions and they blame for allowing themselves to be scammed. eBay is no longer the only the only game out there and if they fail to protect those who line their pockets, they are likely to go elsewhere.

Here is a previous post, I did on eBay, XBox Latest Lure in Auction Scams .

Here is another post, I did (partially to educate eBay customers), The Top (Free) Anti-Fraud Resources Found by Fraud, Phishing and Financial Misdeeds.

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

Did Vladuz hack eBay, or is stockpiled stolen information being used to make it look like he did?


(Picture courtesy of Yahoo Group, eBay_scamkillers)

There is a lot of speculation that eBay was hacked once again, and that Vladuz might be behind the latest episode.

Vladuz, who takes his name from a famous Romanian prince, Vlad Tepes, has plagued eBay with a string of hacking attacks in the past. Vlad Tepes was the inspiration for the novel, Dracula. In Internet folklore, Romanian scammers are often referred to as "Vlads."

Of course, eBay is denying that they were actually hacked. I'll let the reader form their own opinion.

Auction Bytes (Ina Steiner) is reporting:

eBay closed its Trust & Safety discussion board for hours on Tuesday after threads began appearing listing the names and addresses of eBay members. eBay spokesperson Nichola Sharpe said, "We think the fraudster obtained the eBay User names and IDs from previous account takeovers." The credit card information that was published alongside 1,200 names, User IDs and addresses were not associated with the financial information on file for those users at eBay or PayPal, Sharpe said.

Unfortunately, with the amount of account-takeovers caused by Phishing, eBay can suggest other ways the information might have been stolen. Phishing is where users are tricked into giving up their personal details, or downloading malware (crimeware), which steals it right off their hard drive.

I don't know which is worse, that they were hacked in this incident, or that all this information was compromised a long time ago? If it were compromised a long time ago, as eBay states, how much more compromised eBay information is out there?

The Cappnonymous Buds Blog has put together a pretty visual demonstration that makes a pretty good argument that eBay was hacked.

Account-takeovers enable criminals to scam others, using someone else's information. They can also be used to fence (sell) stolen merchandise with a high degree of anonymity.

It should also be noted that stolen payment(credit/debit) card details are often used to purchase the merchandise, which is then fenced.

To cover their tracks, the scammers often dupe people into laundering the proceeds of these sales in work-at-home (job) scams and wiring the money, normally across a border.

Whether Vladuz is behind this latest attack remains to be seen. But the fact remains, that there is a lot of fairly organized crime targeting eBay (my opinion) and other auction sites, on a daily basis.

Previous posts, I've written about eBay and auction fraud can be read, here.

In case anyone is interested in the graphic photo at the top, here is a post I did about a Yahoo Group that call themselves the eBay_scamkillers.

They are an all volunteer group, many of whom have impressive credentials, that are responsible for putting a lot of eBay scammers, where the sun don't shine (prison).

Thursday, September 27, 2007

eBay responds to the alleged Vladuz hacking incident

eBay is responding to the latest (alleged) attack on their site by Vladuz by confirming that the account information was valid, however the credit card numbers were not.

Here is what the Chatter (eBay's blog team) has to say regarding their investigation:

I've been in touch with our operations and security teams, and I have more information I can share with you about yesterday's incident on the Trust & Safety discussion forum. In brief, very early yesterday morning, a fraudster posted contact information and alleged credit card numbers for about 1,200 members on our Trust & Safety discussion forum on eBay.com.

While the issue was very unfortunate, it was clearly falsified to cause public concern. Early on eBay's teams verified that the credit card "data" did not match anything on file for these members on eBay or PayPal. After more investigation, including phone conversations with many of the members, it appears that these numbers were not valid at all.

Each of these accounts was the victim of an Account Take Over, most likely through a successful phishing campaign. eBay has been in contact by phone with many of these members, and there is a My Messages email going out to impacted accounts to further our reach.

1200 successful account-takeovers is a fairly large asset for a criminal to part with, even if the credit card numbers were no good. In the hand of the wrong people, 1200 eBay and PayPal accounts can be used to commit a lot of crime.

Here is a description of how account-takeovers are sometimes used from my original post on this latest incident:

Account-takeovers enable criminals to scam others, using someone else's information. They can also be used to fence (sell) stolen merchandise with a high degree of anonymity. It should also be noted that stolen payment (credit/debit) card details are often used to purchase the merchandise, which is then fenced.

To cover their tracks, the scammers often dupe people into laundering the proceeds of these sales in work-at-home (job) scams and wiring the money, normally across a border.


Although eBay is stating that the credit card numbers in this case were no good, they are for sale, along with account-takeover information on the Internet. Because this information is sold over the Internet, the criminals are able to buy and sell this information (globally) without ever actually meeting each other in person.

As I stated in my earlier post, phishing is a method, where a lot of personal and financial information is stolen, also.

Thus far, all anyone can do is speculate as to how the accounts were compromised. It will be interesting to see if anyone gets to the bottom of what actually occurred.

The Anti-Phishing Working Group tracks phishing activity and many experts claim that eBay and PayPal are the most frequently phished brands. They also have some excellent information on how to avoid being a victim and what to do if you think you've become one.

Auction fraud doesn't only occur on eBay and can happen on any of the auction sites out there. The criminals behind this activity tend to go after what is the most popular, which probably has more to do with why they target eBay than anything else.

If you get phishy e-mails that ask you to provide your eBay, or PayPal account numbers, the Chatter recommends you report them to spoof@ebay.com or spoof@paypal.com. They also recommend to go to their Security & Resolution Center if you encounter a problem.

Another place to report phishy e-mails is CastleCop's PIRT Phishing Incident Reporting and Termination Squad. Please note you can also report this activity on the Anti-Phishing Working Group's site, also.

Reporting a phishing attempt might prevent someone else from becoming a victim. Sadly enough, if you have an e-mail address, you probably see phishing attempts on a daily basis.

Post from the Chatter, here.

Thursday, January 11, 2007

Will competition make it harder to write off fraud costs on auction sites?

Perhaps market forces will be what it takes to better protect buyers and sellers from fraud on auction sites? Competition dictates that the auction providers will have to offer a "better deal" to attract and maintain their customer base.

Internet auctions have become a "very" popular way to buy and sell goods, but they've also attracted a lot of fraud. And fraud seems to be motivating some changes at the most popular auction site, eBay.

eBay is limiting what types of transactions they protect and is banning Google's Checkout on it's site. In addition to this, they are increasing the dollar amount protected with PayPal.

Ina Steiner of AuctionBytes wrote:

eBay will double PayPal Buyer Protection on its site, offering up to $2,000 of coverage for qualified transactions on eBay.com, but is eliminating buyer-protection for non-PayPal transactions. The move is a dramatic effort by eBay to push buyers to use its PayPal online-payment service at a time when it faces increasing competition from Google Checkout, a method it prohibits sellers from accepting on its site.
AuctionBytes story, here.

The story also mentions that eBay no longer protects transactions with financial instruments, such as wire transfers, money orders and checks. Scams using these now "unprotected" financial instruments have been well documented in the auction world.

The message is that if you don't use PayPal, or a credit-card - you aren't protected on eBay.

Not sure if eBay is trying to limit it's own fraud exposure, or if they are marketing fraud protection?

Even though buyers might be getting "slightly" more protection - sellers seem to be more at risk of losing money from fraud than they were before. They are either going to have to limit their "accepted payment methods," or take the chance of losing more money.

And so far as credit cards - "sellers" still are and "always have been" at risk of receiving chargebacks from the financial institution involved.

It will be interesting to see how this progresses and how auction users react.

The auction business is getting more "competitive," and writing off the cost of fraud is going to become "increasingly more difficult."

Here are some previous posts, I've written on auction fraud:

Romanian Second-Chance eBay Scammers Busted

California Issues Alert on Emerging eBay Fraud Trend

How to Spot a Counterfeit on eBay

Bid Reaper, "TELLING IT LIKE IT IS" on eBay

Auction Fraud and the Romanian Connection

How to Protect Yourself on eBay

BBB Worker Takes Job Processing Fraudulent eBay Transactions

Sunday, April 09, 2006

Phishy E-Mails from eBay/PayPal are at a Record High

Phishy e-mails claiming to be from eBay and PayPal seem to be coming into my inbox and bulk mail at record rates. My spam filter used to catch most of them, but now many of them are making their way past it.

Normally, the intent of these e-mails is to steal personal and financial information. Quite often, the information is also used to "take over" legitimate sites and sell bogus, or nonexistent merchandise.

Please note that fraud on auctions isn't exclusive to eBay and PayPal. In fact, the auction business is booming and many new auction sites are being launched. I have no doubt the "Phishermen" will target all of them. Phishing is becoming extremely organized and highly profitable for criminals and they intentionally target whatever is popular, or sells.

I sometimes wonder if they don't hire "marketing experts?"

Here is something, I read this morning from Ina Steiner at Auction Bytes:

PayPal Director of Corporate Communications Amanda Pires said spoofing is an issue PayPal takes very seriously. She could not reveal exact details about what PayPal was doing to fight phishing, but claimed the company is leading the industry with innovative technology and resources dedicated to fighting spoof. "PayPal and eBay employ a dedicated team that focuses just on the spoof issue. Additionally, every second of every day and on every single transaction, PayPal applies its advanced proprietary fraud detection techniques and tools to detect fraudulent activity."

According to Rich Miller, an analyst with Netcraft Ltd., a company that provides security services related to phishing (http://www.netcraft.com/), eBay and PayPal are two of the most frequently targeted companies for phishing schemes. Miller said the best way for such companies to communicate with users is through dedicated message areas users access after they log-in to the company's site. He said the next best advice for users to avoid becoming victims of phishing schemes is to refrain from clicking on links in emails that lead to log-in pages.

Miller said phishing emails create a sense of urgency. In the early days, typos were often a sign of a phishing email, he said, but phishers have cleaned up their spelling over the years. "Phishers will test social engineering tricks," he said. "If it works, they put the additional effort into refining it. They will spend time to make it look legitimate. The people doing it are professionals."

Full story, here.

The best way to defeat the Phishermen is through awareness and by the aware reporting attempts they spot.

The Phishing Incident Reporting and Termination Squad (PIRT) is one place the "aware" can report these scams. The Anti-Phishing Working Group is another place to report "phishy e-mails" and is also a great place to become more aware.

There is also a lot of other fraudulent schemes on auction sites besides "phishing." Unfortunately, in order to be safe doing business on them, becoming aware of all of them is probably a wise idea. Here are some previous posts, I've done relevant to the other schemes:

eBay Fraud from a Personal Standpoint

Counterfeit Travelers Express (MoneyGram) Money Orders Showing Up ...

eBay Fraud Buster

Hard Drives for Nigeria

XBox Latest Lure in Auction Scams

Wednesday, February 08, 2006

NCL Releases the Top Ten Internet Scams of 2005

The National Consumers League has released their 2005 Fraud Trends: Consumers Being Hounded by Internet and Telemarketing Scams.

The "Top Ten" internet scams were:

Auction items never delivered or misrepresented, the average loss was $1,155 and this category accounted for 42 percent of all the complaints.

General merchandise never delivered or misrepresented, the average loss was $2,258 and this category accounted for 30 percent of the complaints.

Nigerian money offers. False promises of riches if consumers pay to transfer money to their bank accounts, the average loss was $6,937 and this category accounted for 8 percent of the complaints.

Fake checks sent for goods or services and victim is told to wire back money, the average loss was $4,361 and this category accounted for 6 percent of the complaints.

Lotteries/lottery clubs. Requests for payment to claim lottery winnings or get help to win, often foreign lotteries the average loss was $2,919 and this accounted for 4 percent of the complaints.

Phishing, fraudulent e-mails asking for personal information, the average loss was $612 and this accounted for 2 percent of the complaints.

Advance-fee loans, loans promised with upfront fee, the average loss was $1,426 and this accounted for 1 percent of the complaints.


Internet Access Services, cost of internet access and other services misrepresented or never provided, the average loss was $1262 and this accounted for 1 percent of the complaints.

Information/adult services. Cost and terms of services not disclosed or misrepresented, the average loss was $504 and this accounted for 1 percent of the complaints.

Work-at-Home Plans. Kits sold on false promises of big profits from working at home, the average loss was $1,785 and this accounted for 1 percent of the complaints.

Although, these statistics are based on complaints made to the National Consumer League, they doubled over the past year (scary).

Wire transfers through non-banking institutions, such as Western Union and MoneyGram were the favorite venue for the fraudsters to have their money sent to them.


Here is an interesting statistic from the survey about eBay. I'm starting to think they deserve an award for ignoring the massive problems fraud has created for their customers:

* In the fall of 2003, online giant eBay removed the link from its Web site to fraud.org. As a result, the number of auction complaints reported to NCL’s fraud center dropped to 1/6 its previous level. Based on statistics prior to eBay’s action, NCL estimates that there would have been 30,720 auction complaints in 2005, representing 71 percent of complaints.

If you are interested in more information regarding eBay, put in keyword "eBay" in the search box at the top of the page.

The National Consumer's League and it's sister site National Fraud Information Center provide a lot of great information on how to avoid being a fraud victim. There are also other relevant (social awareness) resources on the National Consumer League's site. I highly recommend both of them.

You can go directly to the site for the National Consumer League by clicking on the title of this post.





Friday, April 11, 2008

eBay/Craigslist praised by Congressman for efforts to curb sales of stolen military equipment on their sites (?)

I've written a few things about scams and fencing stolen merchandise on auction sites. Recently, the GAO discovered that items stolen from the military are for sale on eBay and Craigslist.

Even more interesting were the results of narrowly focused hearings (my opinion) on this matter in Washington, which can be seen at the bottom of this post. The reason I believe they were "narrowly focused" is because there is no shortage of fraud, phishing and financial misdeeds on auction sites.

Of course, there is also no shortage of ordinary citizens and businesses that have been taken to the cleaners on an auction site. Stolen government items are only a small part of the overall problem.

From the GAO report:

GAO found numerous defense-related items for sale to the highest bidder on eBay and Craigslist. A review of policies and procedures for these Web sites determined that there are few safeguards to prevent the sale of sensitive and stolen defense-related items using the sites. During the period of investigation, GAO undercover investigators purchased a dozen sensitive items on eBay and Craigslist to demonstrate how easy it was to obtain them. Many of these items were stolen from the U.S. military. According to the Department of Defense (DOD), it considers the sensitive items GAO purchased to be on the U.S. Munitions List, meaning that there are restrictions on their overseas sales. However, if investigators had been members of the general public, there is a risk that they could have illegally resold these items to an international broker or transferred them overseas.
Apparently, body armor, MRE (meals ready to eat), uniforms, night vision goggles, NBC (Nuclear Biological Chemical) equipment and even F-14 components were some of the items purchased on eBay and Craiglist by undercover investigators.

The obvious concern would be terrorists, or other not very friendly people getting their hands on some of this stuff.

Given the organized effort on a lot of auction sites to fence stolen merchandise via some pretty sophisticated methods, it's not surprising that the GAO found military equipment for sale on the sites. Many have speculated that these sites are used as a means of fencing the proceeds of what is known as organized retail crime. Of course, less organized criminals obviously sell their goods on auction sites, also.

Organized retail crime obtains their goods by a variety of methods from common theft to using stolen financial instruments. A lot of stolen financial instruments are used to purchase items on auction sites and e-commerce sites. Of course, they are used in more traditional store settings for the same purpose, also.

On eBay, account credentials and payment accounts (PayPal) are phished all the time, enabling an additional layer of anonymity to the schemes. In fact, over the years, many experts have stated that eBay and PayPal are the two most phished brands out there.

One thing not mentioned in the report is that people don't always get what was advertised on these sites. It isn't inconceivable that a complete fighter jet might be put up for sale, paid for and in the end a toy, or "nothing at all" is received by the buyer.

Trust me, this wouldn't be the first time something like this has happened on an auction site.

A lot of counterfeit (knock-off) merchandise is sold on the sites, advertised as the "real thing," also.

Our leaders in Congress reacted by calling Jim Buckmaster (Craigslist) and Tod Cohen (eBay) in to speak with them on the matter.

Anne Broache (CNet) writes:

By calling Craigslist CEO Jim Buckmaster and eBay government relations chief Tod Cohen to Washington for the hearing, the subcommittee seemed to be preparing to place those executives in the hot seat. But the tone of that questioning was actually quite cordial. At the end of the panel, Tierney even praised the companies for "trying very hard" to keep sensitive military goods off their sites and acknowledged the rules of the road aren't the most clear.

Based on her article, which reports that Buckmaster and Cohen were treated with "kid gloves" during the session, my prediction is that little is going to be done to regulate the sale of stolen goods on auction sites as a result of this.

Meanwhile, everyone running for office is saying they will be the one doing something about the problem of special interests in Washington.

On a closing note, I want to commend the GAO for their efforts to expose a problem. I'm just saying it's a shame that no one listened to what they were saying, very carefully.

HTML version of the GAO report, here.

PDF version, here.

Sunday, August 06, 2006

Botnets used to Scam eBay Users

With all the talk about the DefCon (Black Hat) conference in Vegas, this story seems to have gone to the wayside.

Botnets are used by organized criminals - who employ hackers (the malicious sort) - to commit crime on the Internet. Now they are being used on eBay to create phony customer feedback scores and commit auction fraud.

Botnets consist of computer systems that have been taken over after malware is downloaded. The systems are then turned into "zombies" and can be controlled remotely. The "zombie computers" are then used by their owners to commit all kinds of mischief (the illegal type).

Gregg Keizer, TechWeb Technology News reports:

Scammers are using bots to create bogus eBay accounts that boast trustworthy profiles in a new scheme to rip off buyers, a security company said Monday."

The scam, said Sunnyvale, Calif.-based Fortinet, is a new twist on an old con where criminals set up bogus auctions, rake in the proceeds, and then scram, never intending to ship anything to buyers."

Long-time eBay users, however, have gotten wise to such double-crosses, and have learned to avoid auctions where the seller has little or no transaction record and/or little or no buyer feedback.

The new dodge, however, makes that defense useless.

According to Fortinet, the racket uses a bot to create a large number of fake accounts, then applies a spider to scavenge eBay for 1-cent "Buy Now" items, then purchase them.


Once they get a "good rating" going, the scam begins.

Link to the full story by TechWeb, here.

Of course, phishing takes a toll on eBay users, also. Normally, the intent here is to takeover a account with a good rating and then disappear.

Interestingly enough, PIRT run by CastleCops and Sunbelt Software just released the Top Phished Brands - which confirms that eBay and it's sister organization PayPal are phished more than any other brands.

Technology continues to be leveraged by criminals to commit crime on auction sites. In this instance, the recommendation is to read the feedback of the seller "carefully" and beware of anyone with too many 1-cent auctions.

It also pays to ensure the protection for your system is up-to-date and avoid clicking on any links that you aren't certain of.

Here is a good post about how to avoid fraud on auction sites:

How to Protect Yourself on eBay

To avoid phishing scams - which often lead to malware downloads - the APWG (Anti Phishing Working Group) has a good link, here.

Friday, July 06, 2007

If your car gets stolen, eBay might be a good place to look for it!

If your car was recently stolen, it might be a good idea to check out the listings on eBay, according to Dariusz Grabowski, a.k.a (also known as) as the "eBay king of stolen cars."

Rick Hepp at the Star-Ledger reports:

Grabowski and his crew would buy junked or damaged vehicles at auctions and look for similar newer cars to steal. Once they found a car they wanted, they would get its vehicle identification number, usually found in sales ads or right on the car's windshield.

Today's newer car keys can only be duplicated if their computer chips are programmed according to the vehicle identification numbers. Car owners who lose their keys and want duplicates generally go to locksmiths who program the new keys by getting "key codes" from database companies hired by auto manufacturers.

Posing as a locksmith, Grabowski got these codes from the database companies and then made brand new keys. His crew took the keys and simply drove off with the cars.

Before selling the cars, they made them look legitimate by switching the vehicle identification numbers with the ID numbers of the junked cars they had bought.

Grabowski learned how to do all of this by surfing websites that provide technical assistance to locksmiths, and interestingly enough, buying any hardware he needed, on eBay:

You go online, you find anything you need," Grabowski told the investigators in the videotaped interview. "You can go on eBay at this point and purchase any of the equipment you need. Of course, I might pick this up easier than other people.
From there, Grabowski got a business license, which he made on a computer "real quick" and lavished special attention on a female owner of a company licensed to provide locksmiths with the necessary code to clone keys.

Grabowski and crew have all been convicted, but their victims are still paying the price for their misdeeds. New Jersey State Investigator, Jeffrey Lorman was quoted in the article as saying:

The buyers were happy with the cars, they got a great deal. Then we found out about Dariusz and the stolen cars were recovered. Some of these people are still paying for cars they no longer have.
The article mentioned that Grabowski was affiliated with a lot of other Polish nationals, involved in the business of stealing cars, also.

Our friend Dariusz, might or might not be the eBay king of stolen cars. If he is, he isn't alone, at least according to Google. A simple Google search reveals a large amount of information related to scams involving automobiles on eBay, here.

Fraud, Phishing and Financial Misdeeds a.k.a. (sometimes) FraudWar has a lot of information on auction fraud (if anyone is interested), here.

My advice is to be extremely cautious when buying a car on an auction site! If you choose to be cautious a good place to perform due diligence is CarBuyingTips.com, which can be seen, here.

The word is caveat emptor, latin for "buyer beware."

Star-Ledger article, here.

Thursday, April 13, 2006

BBB Worker Takes Job Processing Fraudulent eBay Transactions

A Better Business Bureau worker was recently involved in eBay fraud by taking a part-time (work-at-home job) processing account receivables for criminals from Eastern Europe. According to her, she even checked them out before accepting the job and found nothing that would suggest a scam.

The job was to process payments (primarily from eBay transactions) and wire the money to her employers.

These scams, known as check-cashing schemes solicit people to process fraudulent financial instruments and wire the money to a far-away locale. Their employers normally prefer the use of Western Union, or Money Gram, which offer little to no protection once the money is sent.

News clip from 9News.com in Denver, here.

There is also another version of the work-at-home scam, which entails receiving the stolen merchandise and then reshipping it.

In work-at-home (check cashing) schemes, the worker is normally instructed to set up an account (using their information and good credit) to process the financial instruments. Quite often, they are held financially responsible after the financial instruments are discovered fraudulent and they have wired the money.

No matter what the scam entails, the fraudsters always prefer "unprotected" methods of wiring money. I would highly recommend NEVER wiring money to someone you don't know, or haven't done a lot of business with for a LONG TIME.

To add to the confusion many auction fraud victims buy merchandise from seemingly highly rated sellers when their account is taken over. Account takeovers are normally accomplished via phishing, where a legitimate account holder is duped into giving up their account information.

Phishy e-mails from eBay and PayPal are circulating the internet at a record rate.

Interesting that the BBB worker was savvy enough to do a little "due diligence" on the scam company, which revealed nothing. When I looked at their site, I found two articles that describe activity very similiar to this.

Work-at-Home Schemes

Work-At-Home-Schemes Now Peddled On-Line

I wasn't able to find an article on the BBB regarding "check cashing schemes," but in reality this scam is nothing more than a "mutation" of the "work at home" scheme.

I'd offer to write it for them, but after writing this post, I doubt they will solicit my services.

It's becoming quite common for organized gangs to set up fraudulent businesses as a front for the various scams out there. They are often complete with office space, telephones and even web sites.

I guess the moral of the story is that when a business has no verifiable track record a prudent person should dig a little deeper? I stole that one from my friend Paul, who writes prying1.

Let's face it, processing proceeds from auctions using your own account and wiring the money to Eastern Europe seems a little risky. At least to me, it does.

Sunday, December 04, 2005

XBox Latest Lure in Auction Scams

When anything is hot, such as Microsoft's new XBox, it is best to "let the buyer beware." Todd Bishop of the Seattle Post-Intelligencer is reporting is auction customers on eBay are being tricked into buying empty boxes that once contained the XBox and even pictures of the XBox.

According to the article:

"Capitalizing on shortages of Microsoft's new video-game console, several people have attracted bids as high as $600 or more on eBay this week by offering Xbox 360 boxes -- just empty boxes -- in ways that made it seem, without reading closely, that the items for sale were actually consoles.

The common approach: Acknowledging that the item was merely a box, but surrounding that disclosure with so many pictures and descriptions of the real console and accessories that someone merely skimming the listings might not notice."

For the full story by Todd Bishop go to, Xbox bidders warned to beware Phony auctions are offering the box -- no console, just the box.

In a recent post, I did I wrote, "Many of us will use an increasingly popular method of shopping, which are auction sites. A lot of people have become victims on these sites and e-Bay is the largest player. I prefer the warning information on CraigsList. Craig Newmark (allegedly himself) put this together, "cashier check & wire transfer scams and avoid recalled items. Craigslist gets 3 billion page views a month and although they do charge for certain things (rarely), most of it is free. Furthermore, Craigs provides not only an auction site, but a lot of resources to help people, which again are mostly free."

To read this post, which I put together as a "best practices" resource to avoid fraud during the holiday season, go to, The Top (Free) Anti-Fraud Resources Found by Fraud, Phishing and Financial Misdeeds.

The bottom line is that auction sites, although immensely popular, have attracted a lot of fraud and many a person has become a victim. With more and more people gaining access to the internet, we can expect a this to be a growing trend. These scams always start with, "something that is too good to be true" and the best defense is to "let the buyer beware."

I've received a lot of information on auction scams via readers. If you happen to see something new, please feel free to drop me a line at TedRichardson9925@SBCGlobal.net.

You can also read more on auction fraud by searching keyword "auction fraud" in the search box at the top of this page.

Saturday, October 20, 2007

USPIS Presents: Work@Home Scams: They Just Don't Pay!


The United States Postal Inspectors have produced a pretty telling video showing how Internet criminals lure people into taking jobs that will cause them financial and legal trouble.

The film entitled, Work@Home Scams: They Just Don't Pay shows what happens to people, who accept work-at-home jobs that aren't what they appear to be.

It also speaks to how this problem has grown from ads in the classified section of newspapers and magazines to being plastered all over the Internet.

A lot of us probably see spam e-mails offering these too good to be true jobs that don't make sense on a daily basis. You might also run into one of these scams on a job-site, such as Monster.com.

Another fact is that applying for one of these jobs can lead to giving up your personal information, which will later be used to steal your identity.

Please remember these scams still show up in the classified ads of newspapers and magazines, also.

Here is (what I consider) an interesting story about someone falling for one of these scams that should have known better (my opinion):

BBB Worker Takes Job Processing Fraudulent eBay Transactions

Tuesday, April 26, 2005

Headlines Page

Fraud Related to FEMA
Beware of Flood Damaged Cars
Katrina Fraud Far and Wide
He Wanted to Hack a Hilton
Katrina Fraud Status
Internet Service Providers and Spam
Fraud Relating to Katrina in Full Swing
Getting Revenge on Phishers
Advance Fee Scams with Katrina
FTC Publishes Telemarketing Fraud Legal Actions
Katrina Commission
2Search Promotes Spy/Adware via Deception
Gouging at the Pump
Being Prudent in Donating Money (Katrina)
FBI Reports Fraudulent Activity on Internet Related to Hurricane Katrina
Ensuring the Katrina Victims Receive Your Money
Robbers Posing as FEMA Personnel
Addressing QChex Fraud
More Arrests in Zotob Case
Air Force Files Hacked
Zotob Hackers Caught
Attack of the Worms
Government Job Assistance Scams
Opt Out From Becoming a Victim
More Allegations of Fraud in Iraq
How Much Do We Trust Government Agencies?
Sunbelt Security Discovers a Major Data Theft Case
Retail Crime Becoming Wired
Chevron Accused of Tax Avoidance in Nigeria
Rumor of a Partnership Between Organized Fraud Gangs and Terrorists?
ATM/Debit Card Fraud on the Rise?
Growing Fraud in the Mortgage Industry
Free Credit Reports Might Not be Free
Internet Resume Posting and Fraud
Data Theft Breaches and Identity Theft Products
QChex Alert by the FDIC
The Road to Justice is Slow for Aunt Millie
Fraud Allegations on Weapon Purchases in Iraq
Walmart Reports Executives Committed Fraud
Farewell Mr. Ebbers (Former WorldCom CEO)
Work at Home Scams
Let the Buyer Beware (Summer Travel)
Tax Fraud from Prison Update
McAfee Study on Organized Crime and the Internet
Insurance Fraud and the Military
Reporting Fraud
Investigating Fraud
IBM States Phishing Increases 300 Percent in April
Aftermath of the CardSystems Data Breach
Organized Fraud Gangs
Fraud Gangs Plant Insiders
E-Commerce and Customer Confidence
Cardsystems Violated Mastercard/Visa Credit Card Rules
Identity Theft at Large Corporations
40 Million Credit Files Placed at Risk
Identity Theft (Fraud) Protection by Banks Rated
iPods and Data Theft
Auction Fraud Update
Tax Fraud Proceeds Intended for Overthrow of Government
Industrial Trojan Fraud (Espionage) Discovered
Spyware Bill Approved by House of Representatives
How Deep Does Identity Theft Go?
Robin Hoods Against Internet Fraud
Heroes in the Identity Theft War
Close Call for Check Fraud Informant
Rumor of Increased Sophistication in Phishing
Identity Theft at Investigative Agency
Nigerian Ring Busted in Toledo
Beware of Porn Sites
Adoption Fraud Scheme
Phishing Statistics
Internet Hoaxes
ID Laws and Increased Border Control
More on Postal Money Order Scam
Counterfeit Postal Money Orders
Ahmed Chalabi, Former Minister in Iraq and Convicted Fraudster
Counterfeit Identification
Pyramid and MLM Scams
Keyloggers, Newest Threat in Identity Theft
43 Million Fraud by Student at NYU
A New Twist on Insurance Fraud
More Possible Fraud in Iraq
Insider Identity Theft
Fraud in Prison
Identity Theft Convicts Tell All
Phishing on the Rise
Former FBI Agent in Iraq Makes Fraud/Abuse Allegations
419 Scam, Not only for Nigerians
High Level Arrests in Nigeria
Russian 419 (Advance Fee Scams)
Live from India
Identity Theft
Halliburton Does Business in Nigeria
BCCI, The Beginning of the Globalization of Fraud?
WorldCom CEO
Organized Identity Theft
The FBI Doesn't Notify People They Investigate
Google Phishing Alert
Victims, or ?
Mortgage Fraud
TSUMANI FRAUD
Employee Backgrounds
Update on Qchex and EBay Fraud
Employee Related Identity Theft
Huge Settlement for Corporate Fraud
Fraud on E-Bay
Qchex

Tuesday, October 17, 2006

Feedback Farms and the Need for Third Party Verification Sources eBay

Steve Swoda wrote an interesting commentary about Feedback Farms on eBay.

In his own words:

Last week, Ina Steiner documented the basic story of 'Feedback Farms' on eBay.

I have to be honest, these scams continue to amaze me, and one has to conclude that these scams are damaging and undermining the entire feedback/merchant rating system. If fraudsters can so easily create feedback/merchant ratings in the thousands, then buyers will have to increase their vigilance online. From a buyer's point of view, it continues to be more and more difficult to truly discern good from bad.

Link, here.

Steve makes a good argument about how the need for "third party verification" process is becoming necessary for (prudent consumers) in the e-commerce world.

His company (buySAFE) provides this type of service and is free to the consumer, who chooses to shop where their "seal of approval" has been given.

Friday, October 21, 2005

419 From the Other Side of the Fence

There is an interesting article by Robyn Dixon of the LA Times, who interviewed an allegedly former 419 (Advance fee fraud) scam artist named Samuel. He describes a murky world of cybercafes, where the Nigerian fraudsters congregate and send out the infamous e-mails. According to the article "they even have an anthem "I Go Chop Your Dollars," hugely popular in Lagos, which hit the airwaves a few months ago as a CD penned by an artist called Osofia:

"419 is just a game, you are the losers, we are the winners.

White people are greedy, I can say they are greedy White men, I will eat your dollars, will take your money and disappear.

419 is just a game, we are the masters, you are the losers."


For the video, click here.

Samuel goes on to describe the long lost riches and the dating scams, as well as the money some have made off these schemes. You can read the entire article by going to:

''I Will Eat Your Dollars''

The lyrics of this song might be offensive to some, but it is probably reality to many in Nigeria.

Quite simply, in Nigeria, 419 is a means to escape poverty. For years, foreign companies have made themselves and a "select" few Nigerians extremely rich (via vast oil reserves). Meanwhile the majority of the population lives in conditions that would make a "welfare recipient" in the West appear wealthy. In fact, the CIA estimates that 70 percent of the country lives in poverty, despite the fact that they are a member of OPEC and the eleventh largest producer of petroleum in the world.

To a Nigerian, their perception of these companies is probably just what the song states, or "greedy white men."

There is another headline that has been hitting the press about Microsoft and the Nigerian goverment working together to end scams. Neil Holloway (President Microsoft Europe) said "It's the first-ever agreement Microsoft has signed with an African country to aid law enforcement efforts. Microsoft's aid will include providing information to law enforcement in addition to training. The company has already been working with Nigerian authorities over the last three to six months. We think we have a responsibility to make an impact in this particular area."

Hopefully, the Microsoft Computer Security types have received additional training in self-defense, or have been augmented by other security types, preferably former special forces personnel. Here is the latest CIA Travel report: U.S. State Department's Travel Warning - Nigeria. My understanding is that the oil companies, who have billions invested in Nigeria, have a large budget for security there.

The Nigerian government has also made numerous headlines lately in it's battle against 419. Numerous arrests have been made and money has even been returned to victims. After years of bad press (a lot of it from 419), they do seem to be trying to take measures to improve their image in the world.

Still, the majority of the people live in standards that we couldn't even imagine in the West. I fear, if this problem (which is probably the cause) is allowed to continue, there will always be a steady stream of willing recruits into this seedy business.

Unfortunately, these actions by the Nigerian government and Microsoft only address the suffering created in the West by 419.

If we really want to address the problem of 419 in Nigeria, we probably should take a look putting pressure on the government over there to provide a better standard of living for their people. I would challenge all the foreign companies doing business in Nigeria (particularly from the petroleum industry) to take this to heart.

Microsoft is a newcomer in Nigeria and there is no doubt they are doing a lot of charitable work around the world. I salute them in their efforts and hope their partnership with the Government of Nigeria reduces the amount of suffering created by 419. I would hope that Microsoft and (others) also take the time to address the reason that 419 is a means of escape for many young Nigerian's, like Samuel.

It would be sad that if in the end, they "too" were perceived as "greedy white men."

If anyone is interested in a Nigerian view of corruption in Nigeria, click on the title of this post.

For some of the bad press on the internet regarding 419, here are some sites courtesy of the 419 Coalition (US) :

419eater.com
419 Fraud (US)
419 Legal (South Africa)
419letter.org
African Anti-Fraud Control Agency (AAFA) (Norway)
Africaservice.com (Norway)
American Association of Retired Persons (AARP) (US)
AnthonyParsons.com
Anti African Scam Commission
Artists Against 419 (US)
Australian Institute of Criminology
Avant Solutions Inc. (US)
BankersOnline.com (US)
Bart De Wolf's Site (El Salvador)
Brian Wizard Inc. - 419 Novel Available Now - (US)
BusinessInAfrica.com (US)
California Society of Certified Public Accountants (US)
Canadian Council of Better Business Bureaus
Classic Car Fair (New Zealand)
ConsumerAffairs.com (US)
Consumer Protection Association of America
Crimes of Persuasion (US)
Data Wales (Wales, UK)
Delaware Scam Victims (US)
eBay Scamkillers (US)
Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) (Nigeria)
Edofolks.com (Nigeria)
Email Scams and Frauds (Dr. Robert J. O'Hara's site) (US)
Fighting back at Nigerian 419 Advance Fee Fraud Scammers (UK)
Financial Scandals Website (UK)
Forensic Services SA (South Africa)
FraudAid (US)
Freeman Institute (US)
G2 (US)
Globrocks Information Systems (US)
GreaterThings.com (US)
I Need a Trustworthy and Honest Business Partner (Denmark)
Idaho Department of Finance (US)
InterGOV (US)
International Investigation Services (IIS) (Iceland)
Internet Crime Prevention and Control Institute (US)
Internet Fraud Complaint Center (IFCC) (US)
Internet Scambusters E-Zine (US)
Involution.Org (US)
Lads Of Lagos (US)
London Metropolitan Police (UK)
Loss Prevention Concepts Ltd. (US)
Ministry of Fair Trading, Government of Western Australia
Money From Africa Letter Collection (Poland)
Monitor das Fraudes (Brazil-Portuguese Language)
Monks of Adoration (US)
Motherland Nigeria (US)
Mr. Ugo Watt's Scam Baiter Pages (UK)
National Association of Credit Management (NACM) (US)
National Criminal Intelligence Service (UK)
National Fraud Information Center - Internet Fraud Watch (US)
Nigeria 419 Scam (US)
Nigeria Master Web (Nigeria)
Nigeria Scam Alert (US)
Nigerian Business Proposal (.com) (US)
Nigerian Fraud Email Gallery (US)
NigerianGemScam.com (US)
Nigerian Letters (Australia)
Nigeria Master Web (Nigeria)
Nigerian Nightmare (US)
Nigerian Scams (WONST) (US)
Nigerian Spam.com (India)
Offshore Finance Canada Magazine/Ezine (Canada)
PeaceProject (US)
Pennsylvania Attorney General (US)
Phonebusters (Canada)
Policia Judiciaria (Portugal-Portuguese language)
Poppage1 Site (Canada-India)
Popsubculture.com (US)
Quatloos! (US)
Quatrocantos.com (Brazil-Portuguese Language)
Regulatory Intelligence Agency (RIA) (Vanuatu)
Romance Scam 419 Yahoo Group (US)
RCMP/GRC Royal Canadian Mounted Police (English & French language)
Scam.com (US)
Scambuster419.co.uk (UK)
Scam o Rama (US)
Scams.net (US)
ScamWatch (US)
Scam Victims United (US)
Scott Bidstrup Site - Onsite Personal Viewpoint on Nigeria (US)
Sierra-Leone.org (Sierra Leone)
Silicon Valley Business Law (Law Offices of Thomas Gross) (US)
Snopes.com Urban Legends Reference Pages (US)
South African Police Service (South Africa)
Southwest Georgia Com (SOWEGA.COM) (US)
Spam, Scams and Hoaxes (US)
Stentorian.com (US)
Stop 419s (UK)
StorOslo Sikkerhetstjeneste AS (Norway)
Svensk 419/Nigeriabrev-site (Sweden-Swedish Language)
The Big Scam (Sweden)
The Internet Project (TIP) (Australia)
The Nigerian Scam Buster
The Nigerian Muse (Dr. Mobolaji Aluko) (US & Nigeria)
TheThin.net (US)
United Nigeria Association Tulsa (UNAT) (US)
United States Department of Commerce International Trade Administration
United States Department of State Bureau of Consular Affairs
United States Department of State Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement
United States Department of the Treasury FinCEN
United States Embassy Nigeria
United States Federal Bureau of Investigation
United States Federal Trade Commision
United States National Archives and Records Administration
United States Postal Service
United States Secret Service
United States Senator Russ Feingold
Venture Research Institute (US)
Virginia Attorney General
War On Spam (US)
Waruno Mahdi's Website (Germany)
Web Police (US)
Whatsthebloodypoint.com (US)
ZYRA.org (UK)

Saturday, September 29, 2007

Tools to verify those too good to be true financial instruments you got in the mail


(Counterfeit check picture courtesy of cknlomein at Flickr)

There are a record amount of counterfeit cashier's checks, official checks, money orders, travelers and gift cheques in circulation. This is an attempt to pass on information that the average person can use to tell IF the item is real or a counterfeit (fake).

As a disclaimer -- this is only a guide and if you deposit or cash items from people you don't know -- you do so at your own risk. The quality of these items is getting better all the time.

I’ve put together a list of the known counterfeit items in circulation, along with the current telephone numbers to verify them. You will probably receive these items after being lured with a (too good to be true) get rich quick scheme that doesn't make very much sense.

The best method to verify an item is to go to the maker, or issuer of the check (cheque). They probably will know if they issued it. The key here is to make sure you are speaking with the real issuer (maker) of the item.

Never trust a number provided on the instrument, fake telephone numbers are sometimes set up that will even verify in 411 (information).

Simply stated, as long as the communication companies think they are being paid, setting up a fake number is no problem. We are seeing fake numbers set up by scammers pretty frequently.

Since these numbers are often set up in 411 (information) rather easily, I recommend using Phonevalidator.com. This site provides a service that shows if a number belongs to a cell, or a land line. It also provides telephone directory and Google results for the number queried.

Quite often, fake numbers set-up to verify checks are cell phones.

The Internet is a good way to find the true issuer (maker) of an item. The key is to make sure you are visiting a legitimate site.

Fake websites (especially those pretending to be financial institutions) are a growing problem, also. An easy way to check if a site is legitimate is by using TrustWatch, which verifies whether a site is known (trusted) or not.

If you are interested in taking a look at some fake sites, claiming to be financial institutions the Artists Against 419 has some great examples of them on their site.

A common denominator in most of the scams is that there will be a request to send the proceeds, minus your paltry cut (normally via wire transfer) back to the person sending you the instruments. That is (unless) they are buying goods from you. In this case, your property is what they want you to send to them.

Some of these lures include, but aren't limited to (new lures surface frequently), secret shopper, romance, lottery, work-at-home and auction scams.

The National Consumers League recently set up a site (fakechecks.org), which is a great reference on Internet scams involving checks (complete with visual presentations), here.

So far as auction scams, eBay will no longer offer any protection for paper financial instruments on their site.

Here are some of the known items being counterfeited in large quantities and literally circulating worldwide:

Visa Travelers Cheques: 1-800-227-6811.

MoneyGram Money Orders (counterfeits may still use the old Travelers Express logo): 1-800-542-3590.

US Postal Money Orders: 1-877-876-2455 (mail fraud) option 4, then go to option 2.

American Express Gift and Travelers Cheques: 1-800-221-7282.


FDIC Alerts on the counterfeit cashier's and official checks in circulation, here. There is a feature that allows you to search them. I would try it by using the name of the institution.

Counterfeit cashier's and official checks change almost daily. The counterfeiters use legitimate account numbers and convincing looking check stock that will verify in most automated telephone verification systems.

It's probably good advice to never trust an automated system. In the case of a counterfeit, real ABA/account numbers are used by the counterfeiters. Because the information is real, they get past an automated verification system fairly easily. If you really want to know and believe an item is a counterfeit, ask to speak to a live person, preferably in the fraud department.

If you are dealing with a suspected counterfeit cashier's, or official check, I highly recommend reading a post I collaborated on with Tom Fragala (CEO of Truston Identity Theft Protection Services):

Counterfeit Cashier's Checks Fuel Internet Crime

Bank employees sometimes verify counterfeit instruments as legitimate. In some instances, especially at a teller window, they have been mistaken. If this occurs, you will be notified days later and the bank will take no responsibility.

Even more alarming, I have talked to and get comments/e-mails from people all the time who are getting arrested after trying to negotiate these items.

Here is what I wrote about this growing phenomenon in a previous post, along with my personal speculation as to why this is happening more frequently:
When the check is discovered to be fraudulent, anywhere from right on the spot to about ten days later the person passing the item is left holding the bag. This can translate into a loss of their freedom (getting arrested), being held financially liable, or a combination of both these consequences.
The real victims can probably blame this new phenomenon on all the criminals, who are pretending to be victims and then cashing the items themselves. Here is how I described this in a recent post, where an International task force discovered millions of dollars (face value) of these items destined to be shipped, worldwide:

A new trend has been noted called reverse-scamming, also. This occurs when scammers have the bogus instruments sent to them, cash them and then never follow the instructions to wire the money.

If confronted, these reverse scammers will normally claim to be victims. A key way to pick out a reverse scammer is that, in most instances they forget to wire the money back to the scammer that sent them the counterfeit instrument.